The Ontario Environmental Review Tribunal has rejected Alex Rheault’s request for leave to appeal the issuing of an amended permit for the old Minaki Lodge sewage treatment plant. The Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks had issued the amended permit in March to allow Bob Banman and Bob Schinkel’s 198-unit trailer park on the Lodge site.
The request for leave to appeal, prepared in a collaborative effort by year-round residents of the town and the Conservancy, asserted that MEPC should have required that water quality baseline studies, now thirty-two years old, be updated, and that additional filtration of plant effluent should be required before the effluent flows directly into the Winnipeg River. A report from R.J. Burnside and Associates, the Toronto engineering firm that has worked with the residents and the Conservancy since 2013, backed up those points.
The rejection is not a surprise, as the Tribunal’s standard of review is tilted sharply in favor of Provincial Ministries. Under that standard, Alex’s application had to show that no reasonable person could have made the Ministry decision. Still, since baseline studies are required under the MEPC’s own rules, and since additional filtration is now a common addition to the old treatment process in the plant, we thought it unreasonable for MEPC to refuse to include them. The Tribunal’s decision adopts MEPC’s counter that the size of the Winnipeg River will cure all ills, and that the amended permit, while it could be better, is good enough. The decision is available by clicking here.
Despite this result, the Conservancy and the residents will continue to stay on top of the proposed trailer park development, striving to lessen its dreadful impacts on Minaki’s rare natural environment and special community culture.
The Minaki Conservancy Board
The Minaki Community Association has produced the July/August issue of the Minaki News. It is available by clicking here.
The Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks (“MECP”) and lawyers for developers Bob Banman and Bob Schinkel have responded to Alex Rheault’s request for leave to appeal to the Environmental Review Tribunal two aspects of the amended sewage treatment permit issued by MECP for developers’ proposed trailer park on the Minaki Lodge site. The Conservancy has been cooperating with the group of year-round residents that Alex represents in work on the request for leave.
The responses are a virtual mountain of paper. Two primary pieces of the response — the statement of the MECP Director and the statement of the lawyers — are attached to the links below. Those statements argue that Alex does not have standing to seek leave to appeal, that the Ministry decision not to require updated water quality baseline studies for the Winnipeg River and not to require additional filtration of the treatment plant effluent was reasonable, and that significant environmental harm will not occur.
Alex is entitled to a reply, and that statement is also linked below, along with a supplemental report of R.J. Burnside and Associates, the engineering firm that has been working with the year-round group and the Conservancy since 2013.
The reply addresses again the unusual circumstances of the 2014 permit amendment and of the old Lodge treatment plant with its direct discharge into the Winnipeg River, all in unorganized territory. It asks the Tribunal finally to recognize those circumstances and pay proper respect to the Province’s water.
The Minaki Community Association has produced the May/June issue of the Minaki News. It’s available by clicking here.
In mid-March, the Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks approved the Minaki Lodge redevelopers’ application to amend the permit for the old Minaki Lodge sewage treatment plant, so that the plant could serve a trailer park instead of condominiums.
Minaki resident Alex Rheault, on his own behalf and on behalf of the majority of town residents known as the Alex Rheault group, has requested leave to appeal the amendment to the Environmental Rights Tribunal. That request arises under Ontario’s Environmental Bill of Rights, and may be made only by an Ontario resident.
The request for leave to appeal addresses MOE’s amending of the permit without requiring updated water quality baseline studies for the Winnipeg River and without requiring additional treatment of effluent before it discharges from the 32-year old plant directly into the River. The residents and the Conservancy have been advocating for the correction of those failures for years.
The Conservancy cooperated with the residents in the preparation and submission of the request for leave. Tony Usher, our joint planning consultant, and Anne Egan at R.J. Burnside, our joint engineering consultant, provided quick assistance in meeting the 15-day deadline. If leave to appeal is granted, then an appeal to the Tribunal would follow, most likely based on written submissions. It appears that a ruling on the request for leave will come by the end of June.
The primary components of the request for leave are available by clicking on the links below.
The Minaki Conservancy Board
The Minaki Community Association has produced the March/April issue of the Minaki News, and it’s available by clicking here.
We have a bit of news on the proposed redevelopment of the Minaki Lodge site. After a year’s review, the Ministry of the Environment, Conservation and Parks has approved the application of Bob Banman and Bob Schinkel to amend again the permit to operate the old Minaki Lodge sewage treatment plant.
While there is not a basis for opposing all use of the old plant, the disappointing thing about the MECP decision is that the Ministry ignored comments from the Alex Rheault group of year-round residents, from the Niisaachewan Anishinaabe Nation at the Dalles, and from the The Conservancy, and again failed to bring important aspects of the permit up to current standards. Specifically, MECP’s approval allows the effluent discharge still to flow directly from the plant into the Winnipeg River without additional treatment on land or in the plant, and allows reliance on required water quality baseline studies that are now over thirty years old.
The approved amendment to the permit does change the permitted use on the site from condominiums to a trailer park, in line with developers’ apparent plans for the site.
The January/February issue of The Minaki News is out, thanks as always to Barb Mach and the Minaki Local Services Board, and is available by clicking here.
The November/December 2019 issue of The Minaki News is out, and is available by clicking here.
The September/October 2019 issue of The Minaki News is out, and is available by clicking here.